top of page

Capstone Project:
Tiered Reflection Cycle

This capstone project explores how structured reflection can be embedded directly into the artmaking process to help students become more intentional, analytical, and confident problem solvers within the classroom.

Rather than treating reflection as a final activity completed after a project, this framework integrates reflection during the act of creating, allowing students to identify challenges, revise their thinking, and apply meaningful changes to their work in real time.

Capstone Focus

  • Development of the Tiered Reflection Cycle (TRC) instructional model

  • Integration of reflection directly into the drawing and design process

  • Research and adaptation of existing reflective frameworks for middle school learners

  • Use of iterative drawing exercises focused on revision and intentional decision making

  • Support for English Language Learners (ELLs) and diverse learning needs through accessible reflective structures

  • Emphasis on process, progress, and creative problem solving rather than technical skill alone

  • Exploration of how reflective thinking can improve student engagement and ownership over learning

 

 

Research and Instructional Foundations

The project draws inspiration from several established reflective frameworks, including:

  • “What, So What, Now What”

  • Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle

  • Bassot’s Integrated Reflective Cycle

  • Universal Design for Learning (UDL)

  • Social Emotional Learning (SEL)

  • Iterative design and critique practices used within visual development workflows

Through classroom implementation and student observation, these ideas were simplified and adapted into a reflection process designed specifically for repeated use within middle school art education.

 

 

Tiered Reflection Cycle (TRC)

The TRC framework guides students through short reflective cycles during the creative process:

  1. Identify
    What did you do?

  2. Explain
    What is not working?

  3. Refine
    What will you change?

Students revisit these steps multiple times throughout a lesson, allowing reflection to become an active tool for revision rather than a passive closing activity.

​

​

Capstone Goals

  • Help students develop stronger problem solving and revision skills

  • Increase student ownership over the creative process

  • Reduce disengagement caused by uncertainty or lack of direction

  • Create a reflection system that is adaptable, repeatable, and accessible

  • Encourage students to analyze challenges and make intentional changes in their work

bottom of page